Canadian Cities Prove Best & Worst for NHL Jock Tax
Updated: Oct 18, 2023
On July 1st when Tom Gilbert left the Florida Panthers to sign with the Montreal Canadiens he went from one of the lowest taxed organization in the NHL to the highest.
This past summer, 138 NHL free agents changed teams. While each of the player’s salary were registered in gross dollars, teams and players need to be aware of how each NHL team’s unique tax situation affects the actual after tax value of the contract. Therefore each contract offer should be judged by the net value of the contract, as opposed to the gross amount offered.
This season, a player in the NHL will potentially play and be taxed in up to 26 different jurisdictions within the United States and Canada. While all athletes incur federal tax liability on their earnings, their exposure to state, provincial and local income tax will be dictated by a team’s home and road schedule and therefore each team with their own distinct tax liability.
The Jock Tax Index (JTI)
The Jock Tax Index (JTI) quantifies and correlates each NHL team’s unique tax situation to determine a player’s comparative after tax value depending on the team and city in which they play.
The JTI provides teams and players the ability to quantify offers made from multiple teams and determine the true value of each proposal. It ranks each of the 32 NHL teams according to the federal, state, and city income tax liability based on their game schedule.
Using the guidelines outlined in my article “When is a CPA as important as your ERA?,” published in the Spring 2009 issue of Marquette Sports Law Review, the JTI assumes each individual will earn the 2014 league average ($2,400,000), file as “single,” and not miss any games. The only deductions assumed taken on Schedule A of the federal return (“itemized deductions”) are state income taxes paid during the year, and itemized deductions are phased out for large income taxpayers. It should also be noted that all individuals were considered residents of the state or province in which they played and filed as residents of the United States.
In analyzing the different tax liabilities between teams there are a few observations that can be made: First, the average net income retained after tax of the NHL is 54.78% which is similar to other major league sports (The NFL retains the highest at 57.6% and Major League Baseball is the lowest at 53.99%).
Second, the NHL’s JTI variation of 11.78% in the NHL’s net income retained when comparing the highest to lowest is 70% greater than either baseball (MLB 6.92%) or football (NFL 7%).
Finally, although it may be perceived that players who play in Canada are taxed higher than those who play in the United States, the interesting fact is that this is only partially correct. Canada’s two franchises based in Canada’s Alberta province have the lowest tax liability of any team in the NHL. A member of the Edmonton Oilers can expect to retain the greatest percentage of their income, keeping 61.26%, while one playing in Calgary retains 60.88%. In contrast, those hockey players playing in the province of Quebec and Ontario are among the highest taxed. A member of the Montreal Canadiens, based in Quebec, can expect to retain only 49.39% of their income after tax for a JTI of 11.87, while one playing in Toronto or Ottawa will retain 51.98% of their income with a JTI of 8.9
Although the Canadian teams playing in Alberta, Quebec and Ontario represent the extremes, each of the 30 team in the NHL has their own distinct tax consequences that are represented by their own specific JTI rating. In reviewing the NHL’s JTI the following ten teams have the highest JTI and therefore the player’s playing on these teams have the lowest total value from their income.
Team
JTI
Montreal Canadiens
11.49
Anaheim Mighty Ducks
9.84
San Jose Sharks
9.83
Los Angeles Kings
9.82
Ottawa Senators
8.90
Toronto Maple Leafs
8.90
Minnesota Wild
8.25
New York Rangers
7.74
Washington Capitals
7.73
Buffalo Sabres
7.71
Two good examples of how the JTI can compare the true value of a contract offer is in reviewing two signings from this past off-season.
Tom Gilbert
On July 1st the Montreal Canadiens signed former Florida Panther Defenseman Tom Gilbert to a two year $5.6 million contract, but the question that the JTI answers is at what premium did they need to pay?
The JTI shows that the Canadiens needed to pay a premium of nearly a million dollars above what the Panthers could have offered in order for Gilbert to retain the same after tax value.
Team
Gross Salary
AAV
Difference ($)
Difference (%)
Canadiens
$5,600,000.00
$2,800,000.00
–
–
Panthers
$4,698,130.13
$2,349,065.07
$901,869.87
19.20%
Gilbert’s after tax value on his Montreal Canadiens two-year $5.6 contract is $2,787,471.73. In order for Gilbert to receive the same value from the Panthers, they could have offered him $901,869.87 less and the two deals would have had the same after tax value.
Anton Stralman
Stralman, was another July 1st signing who left the Rangers and signed with the Tampa Bay Lightning. Unlike the Gilbert signing where the Canadiens needed a premium to sign Gilbert, Tampa Bay’s JTI of 2.128 allowed them to offer a discount in order for them to match the net value of the Rangers.
Team
Gross Salary
AAV
Difference ($)
Difference (%)
New York Rangers
$24,859,713.73
$4,971,942.75
–
–
Tampa Bay Lightning
$22,500,000.00
$4,500,000.00
$2,359,713.73
10.49%
In order for the Rangers to match Tampa’s after tax value of $13,304,920 they would have needed to offer Stralman $471,942.75 more each year over the length of his five year deal.
Summary
Stralman and Gilbert are only two of the 138 free agents that changed teams this summer, but they provide excellent examples of how the JTI can be used in evaluating the true value from multiple offers. The JTI provides agents and athletes the ability to take jurisdictions with different tax liability and make a comparative analysis prior to signing. Should you be interested in learning more about the JTI please don’t hesitate to contact our office and we’ll show you how it can help you in analyzing your next negotiations.
ALAN POGROSZEWSKI is an Assistant Professor of Sports Studies at St. John Fisher College and the President of his own tax consulting business whose clientele include professional athletes performing services on three separate continents. Prior to accepting his position at St. John Fisher College, Mr. Pogroszewski was the Vice President of Business Operations for Sports Consulting Group, a firm that specializes in the representation of professional hockey players. Mr. Pogroszewski received his M.B.A. from Rochester Institute of Technology in 1996 and his M.S. in Taxation from St. John Fisher in 2003.
©2015, Alan Pogroszewski. All Rights Reserved.




https://dh88.llc/ mình ghé qua xem thử, chủ yếu đọc phần giới thiệu chứ chưa tìm hiểu sâu. Mình hay có thói quen nhìn tiêu đề trước rồi mới chọn đoạn để đọc, nên thấy trang có mục câu hỏi riêng cũng khá tiện. Những chuyện như mỗi người được tạo bao nhiêu tài khoản có ghi sẵn, không phải tự đoán hay tìm trong một đoạn giới thiệu dài. Mình thích có thông tin kiểu này hơn là chỉ thấy những lời giới thiệu chung chung. Còn các thông tin khác thì mình mới đọc sơ thôi, chưa kiểm chứng nên cũng không nói thêm. Nhìn qua, cách đặt tên từng phần khá thẳng vào nội dung, đọc đến đâu…
SC88 bảo vệ thông tin cá nhân của người dùng như thế nào? Mình cũng tò mò chuyện này nên ghé xem thử, mà mới lướt qua thôi chứ chưa đọc kỹ phần quyền riêng tư. Thành ra mình chưa biết họ lưu hay xử lý dữ liệu cụ thể ra sao, cái đó chắc phải xem nội dung chính sách mới nói được. Còn lúc mở trang, mình thấy menu khá dễ nhận ra, không phải nhìn quanh một hồi mới biết chỗ bấm. Mình hay ngại mấy trang dồn chữ sát nhau nên cách chia nội dung ở đây nhìn cũng dễ chịu. Chưa quen trang mà vẫn theo dõi được thì đỡ mất công mò hơn chút.…
qq88 khuyến mãi là cụm mình gặp lúc đang đọc mấy bình luận, thế là rảnh tay mở ra ngó thử. Mình chưa đọc sâu nên cũng chỉ nói chút về phần giao diện thôi nha. Có hai điểm khá hợp mắt mình là menu dễ nhận ra với các phần nội dung không bị dồn sát vào nhau. Bình thường vào một trang lạ, mình hay phải kéo lên kéo xuống để tìm chỗ muốn xem, nên kiểu sắp xếp này thấy đỡ mất công hơn chút. Mình thích có khoảng trống vừa đủ để lướt tới đâu biết đang nhìn phần nào tới đó, chứ chữ nối nhau liên tục thì hơi ngại đọc. Thanh menu nằm ở…
hi88 khuyến mãi là cụm mình thấy được nhắc đến nên tò mò ghé qua xem giao diện thế nào, chứ cũng chưa tìm hiểu kỹ nội dung bên trong. Lúc mới mở trang, mình chủ yếu nhìn cách chia các khối thông tin với vị trí menu, vì mấy chỗ này mà rối quá thì mình thường ngại xem tiếp. Nhìn sơ thì bố cục khá dễ theo dõi, các phần có khoảng cách nên không có cảm giác chữ nghĩa chen chúc nhau. Mình cũng chỉ lướt một lúc thôi, chưa bấm hết từng mục nên không nhận xét gì sâu hơn. Riêng menu nằm ở chỗ dễ thấy, nhìn vào là nhận ra khu vực để chuyển…